| Symphony No. 8, Op. 65 | ||
| 1 | Adagio |
27 . 44 |
| 2 | Allegretto |
6. 34 |
| 3 | Allegro non troppo |
6. 48 |
| 4 | Largo |
9. 39 |
| 5 | Allegretto | 15. 33 |
Total playing
time 1.06.29 |
||

| Dmitri
Shostakovich (1906-1975) Symphony No. 8 Russian National Orchestra Conducted by: Paavo Berglund PTC 5186 084 DSD recorded |
|

![]()
Profoundly human
Not until later on, in his posthumously published memoirs, did Shostakovich
provide a personal insight into his Symphony No. 8 in C minor, Op. 65,
which he completed on September 9, 1943 in only two months’ time,
following a short, yet agonisingly dry creative period: “The Seventh
and the Eighth are my ‘Requiem’.” At the time, his first
comments on the new work were very different, and (as was usual during
Stalin’s regime, one should add) meaningless: “This work mirrors
my thoughts and feelings following the joyous reports on the first victories
of the Red Army.” For sure ... After all, it would be hard to come
up with another 20th-century symphony that sounds as inscrutable and sadly
fateful as Shostakovich’s Eighth.
Following his triumphant Leningrad Symphony, the composer had deeply disappointed
the expectations of the Apparatschik with this work, as a great part of the
Eighth is pensive and melancholy, and does not announce the victory of the
Red Army at Stalingrad. Quite the opposite, instead of producing emotional
and enduring symphonic music, Shostakovich the man not only expresses his
deep mourning of the dreadful tragedy of the Second World War and its countless
victims, he also announces in the most deeply pessimistic tone the individual
suffering of the people in the Soviet Union, who (also before the war) suffered
and died under Stalin’s reign of terror. Shostakovich’s hope
that the authorities would interpret the resignative tone of the work as
a consequence of the German aggression, was rapidly dashed, and thus the
Eighth was censured in1948, after Shostakovich, Prokofiev and other leading
composers had been accused of “formalistic tendencies”. The symphony
was banned from the concert podium, and numerous radio recordings of the
work were destroyed.
In the urgency of its individual message, the Symphony No. 8 often exceeds
the pain level of the listener. It functions as absolute music, without a
programme being imposed from the outside. The Symphony contains five movements,
of which the first represents a gigantic introduction, lasting almost 25
minutes. Within the first bars, this movement presents the nucleus of both
the music and the content of the entire work – second intervals in
octaves in the low strings with double-dotting at the intervals C – B
flat – C, which creep in an absolutely insidious manner into the world.
The tempo increases gradually during the course of the movement, the themes
are subjected to dramatic, even apocalyptic intensifications, until the motif
from the beginning is hurled out by the brass in fff at the climax of the
movement, distorted by the percussion. The in parts strident, even screeching
instrumentation (piccolos!) provides an expressive release full of unrestrained
power. Grief has perhaps never been portrayed in a more tragic, dreadful
and individual manner in music. The following Allegretto is a grotesquely
distorted march, in which Shostakovich parodies a paraphrase of the German
waltz Rosamund. As far as harmony is concerned, the composer distances himself
here from the major-minor system. The third movement is formally speaking
a toccata. In comparison to the first movement, a perfectly simple piece
of music: however, in its motor functions and rhythmic persistence it keeps
the listener in its ban. Without interruption, the crotchet passages course
throughout the entire movement like a machine, shaded by screeching interjections
from the woodwind. Pure nihilism. The orchestral power swells up towards
the end of the movement, after which the fourth movement, a Largo-Passacaglia,
follows on immediately. A continuously tragic style of writing is characteristic
for this movement with melodic sequences full of semitones. The bass theme
appears twelve times, above which the other instruments seem to hover. This
is followed without a break by the Finale, which Detlef Gojowy interpreted
as “’autonomous music’ in the sense of a Bach Invention”.
The pastorally tinted movement is constructed in episodes and presents a
Fugato, which ends in catastrophe. And thus Shostakovich denies his Symphony
No. 8 any kind of resolution, or apotheosis. The work fades away in pianissimo,
questioning, resignative
Paavo Berglund
For many years, Paavo Berglund conducted the Finnish Radio Symphony Orchestra
as well as the Helsinki Philharmonic Orchestra in his native Finland. From
1987 to 1991, he was chief conductor of the Stockholm Philharmonic Orchestra,
and from 1993 to 1996 he held the same position with the Royal Orchestra
in Copenhagen.
In England, where he was chief conductor of the Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra from 1972 until 1979, he has also worked closely with the London Philharmonic Orchestra and the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra. Furthermore, he has toured Europe with the BBC Symphony Orchestra, the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra and the Chamber Orchestra of Europe.
He has conducted many major European orchestras, including the Berlin Philharmonic, the RSO Berlin, the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra, the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra, the London Philharmonic Orchestra, the Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra, the Russian National Orchestra, the Zurich Tonhalle Orchestra, the Orchestre de la Suisse Romande, the Swedish Radio Symphony Orchestra, the Helsinki Philharmonic Orchestra and the Orchestre National de France. He is regularly invited to guest-conduct the Oslo Philharmonic Orchestra and the Chamber Orchestra of Europe.
In the USA, Paavo Berglund has conducted the Minnesota Symphony Orchestra, the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra, the Boston Symphony Orchestra and the St. Louis Symphony Orchestra, as well as the New York Philharmonic Orchestra, the Los Angeles Philharmonic Orchestra and the National Symphony Orchestra in Washington, among others. In the autumn of 1997, he returned to conduct the Cleveland Symphony Orchestra, the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra and the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra. In December 1997, he gave concerts with the Russian National Orchestra in Moscow, St. Petersburg and Tampere. Other activities included guest-conducting appearances with the Chamber Orchestra of Europe at the Edinburgh and Helsinki Festivals in August 1998, where he conducted all Sibelius’ Symphonies. During 2004/2005 he undertook a tour with the London Philharmonia Orchestra. In October 2004, there were concerts with the London Philharmonic Orchestra, where he returned in January 2005. Further engagements for 2005 included concerts with the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra.
Paavo Berglund has recorded all of Sibelius’ symphonies for EMI with both the Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra and the Helsinki Philharmonic Orchestra. He recorded this cycle for the third time with the Chamber Orchestra of Europe for Finlandia/Warner Bros. He has also recorded all the Nielsen symphonies with the Royal Danish Orchestra.
His recordings have received many prizes, among others a “Grammy” nomination for his world-première recording of Sibelius’ Kullervo Symphony, and the “Diapason d’Or” for his Nielsen cycle. His extensive discography also includes symphonic works by Shostakovich, Smetana and Dvorák.
“This is the second SACD recording of the Eighth. The first, part of a complete traversal by Dmitri Kitajenko and the Gürzenich Orchestra of Cologne, I have not heard. But this effort by Berglund and the excellent Russian National Orchestra, recorded in Moscow in June 2005, would be hard to beat as regards both recorded sound and the performance itself.”
J. Scott Morrison, Amazon.com
“Berglund and the Pentatone engineers have scored a triumph….Without
excellent recorded sound, listening to this work can be even more painful
than is inherent in the music. Pentatone has exceeded itself in providing
surround sound in every respect as good as it gets. Highly recommended”
---SA-CD.net
“There are now performances of this symphony for every taste, from the
fast and urgent Caetani (Arts Music) to the very slow and grave second Previn
recordings (DG), but none offer quite Berglund's interpretive point of view,
so there really is something new here for collectors to enjoy. The engineering
also is very good both in stereo and multichannel formats, and the bottom
line is that you may quibble with certain details, but there's no question
that Berglund delivers an intelligent, moving, and fully formed conception
of this powerful and emotionally draining symphony.”
---Davis Hurwitz, Classics Today
“Pentatone's excellent Shostakovich symphony cycle is shared thus far
by three conductors: Vladimir Jurowski (Nos. 1 and 6), Mikhail Pletnev (No.
11) and this new issue with Berglund conducting the Symphony No. 8. Berglund
might seem an odd choice to conduct Shostakovich, but he and the superb Russian
orchestra provide a fine performance beautifully recorded.”
Robert Benson, classicalcdreview.com
“One of the successes of this recording is the feeling that these
are unedited takes (the occasional studio noise remains as do some imperfections
in the playing, none of which matters in the face of the musical gravitas) – the
ebb and flow of paragraphs and climactic tension are organic and have a build-quality
commensurate with the concert hall.”
---Colin Anderson, classicalsource.com
“In the opening movement, Berglund & the RNO manage what others
often do not - namely to convince the listener of the structure and the emotional
narrative of the work….In short, this shattering music receives the
playing it fully deserves here from Berglund and the RNO. This RNO focused
series from Pentatone is fast turning into the most exciting cycle of the
Shostakovich symphonies to be put down on disc and is easily the best recorded.”
---John Broggio, SA-CD.net
Russian National Orchestra
The Russian National Orchestra has been in demand throughout the music world
since its 1990 Moscow début. The first Russian orchestra to perform
at the Vatican and in Israel, the RNO maintains an active schedule of touring
and is a frequent guest at major festivals. Of the orchestra’s 1996
début at the BBC Proms in London, the Evening Standard wrote: “They
played with such captivating beauty that the audience gave an involuntary
sigh of pleasure.” By the time of the RNO’s 10th anniversary,
the orchestra had been reviewed as a “major miracle” (Time
Out New York) and classical music’s “story of the decade” (International
Arts Manager). In 2004, the RNO was described as “a living symbol
of the best in Russian art” (Miami Herald) and “as close to
perfect as one could hope for” (Trinity Mirror).
Gramophone magazine listed the first RNO CD (1991) as the best recording of Tchaikovsky’s Pathétique in history, and reviewed it as follows: “An awe-inspiring experience; should human beings be able to play like this?”. Since then, the RNO has made more than 30 recordings for Deutsche Grammophon and PentaTone Classics, with conductors such as Mikhail Pletnev, Mstislav Rostropovich, Kent Nagano and Alexander Vedernikov.
In 2003, the orchestra signed a new multi-disc agreement with PentaTone Classics. One of the first results of this collaboration – a recording of Prokofiev’s Peter and the Wolf and Beintus’ Wolf Tracks, conducted by Kent Nagano – won a 2004 Grammy Award, which made the RNO the first Russian orchestra ever to win the recording industry’s highest honour.
Unique among the principal Russian ensembles, the RNO is independent of
the government and has developed its own path-breaking structure. It is perhaps
the only orchestra to have established a Conductor Collegium, a group of
internationally renowned conductors who share the podium leadership.
Another innovation is Cultural Allies, which was created in 2001. Cultural
Allies encompasses exchanges between artists in Russia and the West, and
also commissions new works. Prominent RNO partners in Cultural Allies include
Dave and Chris Brubeck, Hélène Grimaud, Sophia Loren, Wynton
Marsalis, John Corigliano and Michael Tilson Thomas.
The Russian National Orchestra is supported by private funding and is governed by a distinguished multinational board of trustees. Affiliated organizations include the Russian National Orchestra Trust (UK), the Russian Arts Foundation and the American Council of the RNO.